The Editor, Madam:

I have read in earnest your explanation/analysis regarding the United States passport requirement for American citizens returning from the Caribbean and the two-year extension offered to cruise ship passengers vis-à-vis airline passengers, and the fact that the law as it relates to airline travellers requiring passports become operational in January 2007.

Contrary to the erroneous and fictitious explanation offered by politicians and hotel magnate, Mr. Gordon Butch Stewart, that the United States position of requiring passports to re-enter is based on the current relationship that several Caribbean countries have with Mr. Hugo Chavez, the President of Venezuela, your elucidation and clarification of this salient issue, specifically Mexico's preferential treatment and status is extremely appreciated.

Indeed, as you appropriately contend, several governments within the Caribbean did not respond proactively and seriously regarding the Western Hemispheric Travel Initiative. Consequently, when the law becomes operational, it will definitely have an impact on the Caribbean with regard to foreign exchange earnings. Again, your information and insight on this issue is immensely instructive.

I am, etc.,

Esteban Agosto Reid, Ph.D.

Mandeville, Manchester